I have been wearing this mascara for twenty-five years. I've tried many others through the years, but always come back to this one. It has always been gentle on my eyes and lasts as long as any of the luxury mascaras. (I have watery eyes. And, nothing truly ever lasts all day.) Unfortunately, something has been changed in the formula, and it is causing an allergic reaction for me. In the trash it goes. I'm so disappointed.

I bought this mascara because all the reviews say it's good for dry, sensitive eyes. I just learned that Cover Girl change the ingredients a year ago and have added CARNAUBA WAX. Well, that's one of the ingredients that dries out sensitive eyes. Great job Cover Girl.

I've used this specific 3-N-1 Water Proof Mascara from Covergirl for decades. However, in the past 3 years or more, the quality and quantity of product inside every new cylinder has diminished greatly. Two days ago I purchased another 3-N-1 Water Proof Mascara and when I pulled out the wand from the cylinder the first time, it was covered in a thick, dry paste. Again. Try putting that on your eyelashes? Globs of mascara, clumped eyelashes, it's a mess trying to use it. In the past, a brand new mascara would have more of a liquid-y consistency. What's happening to Covergirl's quality control? How do you measure the quantity of mascara inside of your products? Do I have to start buying another brand of mascara?

I have been using this professional 3 n 1 waterproof black for years. The last 2 to 3 tube's, i have noticed, the product is not the same. There is hardly any mascara in the tube, thinking it was dried out, purchased another, same! So tried a different store, same! Also very thick. I just switched mascara.

I can not open! I would love to try product but can not get top off! Is there a special trick?

This mascara was okay. I didn't really feel like it did anything for my lashes. No volume, no length. However, it was not clumpy at all. I wouldn't get it again

The volume was outstanding, no. Clumping so great separation with the brush. Its builadality is not too heavy, and it's waterproof. What else could you want?

Clumpy, did not sit well on lashes. Difficult to remove. Felt heavy and thick. Very drying formula. Brush was ok, but did not fan the lashes out. Coats felt very thick and did not hold up well.

Sadly I don't really like this mascara because the packaging broke when it was in a makeup bag. It also isn't really waterproof. It does give you natural lashes with clumps though. It only gives a slight curl. Wouldn't recommend this product.

I never used to wear mascara but when I decided to try it, I bought this one and I instantly loved it! It goes on nice and smooth, it's not chunky at all, and it stays on my lashes and keeps them looking freshly curled, long and thick.