I love how skinny the applicator brush is for a tight liner BUT the spring-loaded cap always malfunctions. The cap will just POP off, often sending my eyeliner flying. Or if it pops off in my makeup bag, covers my products in ink. And then it just dries out. This has happened more than once to me. Don't think I will repurchase as I never get full use of the liner.

I loved this eyeliner because it never smudge. It was hard to find in stores and all of a sudden I can find it now but the formula is different. It smudges.

Love this eyeliner but what is up with the faulty caps that shoot off like a rocket. It makes the eyeliner dry out because the caps just pop off every single time. I thought at least 20 of these islanders has been the same situation every time and the company won't give me a refund unless I have a ton of information which I don't have because I don't save that kind of stuff.

It is really good my eyes tend to water a lot and it all stayed on and didn't smudge or anything it was very light weight and comfortable and when applying it I only had to use one coat and it dried right away within seconds you do not need very much of it and it is very affordable.

I love this eyeliner. It creates the most crisp perfect lines i have ever seen in a liner. Its a little drying since it is cryproof. But I love it so much. Its so pigmented. Bougie on a budget

I picked up the Wet n Wild Breakup Proof Skinny Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner in a total pinch before an out-of-town work trip and honestly… I was shooketh. I've been loyal to my KVD liner for years because nothing beats a crisp sharp wing on my hooded lids… or so I thought. This little drugstore gem proved me wrong in the best way.The control is unreal. The skinny applicator gives you so much precision that getting a perfect base and flick feels effortless. The brush doesn't fray doesn't skip and lays down the blackest black line that stays saturated from start to finish. It's incredibly easy to map out a wing fill it in and keep everything symmetrical… which we all know is half the battle. No wonky wings here!And the wear? Zero fading. Zero transfer onto my hooded lids. It stays exactly where you put it. Once it dries down it's locked in but without that crunchy stiff look some waterproof liners give. It survived a full day of work travel humidity… you name it.For the price the performance is honestly insane. If you want a sharp wing precise control and true-black (matte) payoff that doesn't budge this liner delivers. I'm still shocked I found something that rivals my KVD… and possibly beats it.

I don't use liquid eyeliner often but when I do it has to be Wet N Wild breakup proof Skinny Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner! It lasts all day! I never have to reapply! It's easy to use and doesn't take all day to get it right!

The durability of this product is amazing. The precision is great. It has a very pointy tip that allows the precision to be right on. It is a value for your money. The packaging is very sleek and the application is amazing with the pointy tip. It goes on very smoothly.

This eyeliner is surprisingly good for the price. The tip is super thin which makes it easy to draw precise lines and get a sharp wing. It glides on smoothly and dries down quickly without smudging. I wore it for a full day and it stayed put through humidity and even a light workout definitely waterproof. My only issue is that it can fade a bit on oily lids so using a primer helps. The packaging is lightweight and easy to carry. Great value overall and perfect for everyday wear or travel.

This eyeliner is a game-changer for anyone seeking bold long-lasting color without breaking the bank. Its ultra-black pigment delivers a rich intense line that stays put throughout the day. Whether you're facing humidity tears or a busy schedule this liner holds strong without smudging or fading. Plus it's easy to remove at the end of the day.