Most liked positive review

Best I've tried

I gave this 5 stars because it has such a nice range of colors, it isn't pricey and it stays put most of the time depending on the color. I've been using this eyeliner for years and it's really all I buy because I've tried other all day eye liners and they always are gel and run or liquid which I do...n't use because I like my eyes to look more matte. What I've experienced is that the brown is really soft as well as the black. Sometimes the eyeliner does break a tiny bit off so you should only roll it a little at a time..: easy fix. The black sometimes smudges but the green, blue , and grey are harder consistency and to me they are perfect. Never smudge and last all day. It is annoying with some of the softer colors ( black and brown) because after about 4 hours I need to go under the eye and put some concealer and then it again lasts another 4 hours or more without smudging. The teal color from my experience is EXTREMELY hard ... so when I put it on it feels like it's scraping the top a little bit but not the inner eye. It's just a very dense consistency. However they last ... they actually last and most don't smudge at all so that's a 100% in my book! Compared to all the money I've wasted on other products. I haven't tried the purple but I want to.