
- $4.99/ 1ea
Product availability and price subject to change based on offers available at pick-up or delivery time.
Product Number: 21540312004_EA
We do our best to be accurate with respect to the advertised ingredients, nutritional information, product images, country of origin, and descriptions listed on our app/website. As this information may be changed by manufacturers at any time, we strongly recommend that you always read the product packaging carefully for the most current and accurate ingredient, nutrition, country of origin, or other product information (including warnings) before using or consuming any products. If you have food sensitivities or allergies, you should always read the actual product packaging to ensure safety of the product for your situation. Please do not solely rely on the information provided on this app/website.
We may, at our sole discretion, limit or cancel quantities purchased to ensure reasonable requirements and availability for all customers.
Most liked positive review
I miss the dark green!
I love the espresso eyeliner. It locks in place and stays all day. There used to be a dark green shade in this eyeliner that I really miss! It was my go to eyeliner for my green eyes. I wish you would bring back the dark green!
Most liked negative review
WAAA WAAAA WAAAA:(
i purchased this as a new line to try. i love the rasin color as i have green/blue eyes and its a color that is a go to for me. the first time wearing it it was ok i use it on my upper waterline as well as lower.. it clumped in my lashes and bleed onto my skin. i was not outside nor sweaty. By ...
Reviewed by 22 customers
Can't sharpen
I bought the But First Espresso eyeliner a couple of weeks ago. I've used it maybe 3 times and I love it, but there's no way to sharpen it or get more product out! As many others have commented before... the tip and pencil seem to be made of hard plastic, not wood, so sharpening it is impossible. There's no twist mechanism either to push the product up. Customer Service has responded to a few reviews saying just sharpen it. BUT IT IS PLASTIC! YOU CAN'T SHARPEN PLASTIC!!!! Please tell me if there is something I'm missing

Finally! A colored eyeliner that actually lasts!
I absolutely love this liner! It glides on like silk and wears like iron. You also get much more product than with retractable liners simply by sharpening the point. Best eyeliner ever!
The best eyeliner I've ever found!!!
Stay n play gel eyeliner is the best n I mean the best and it stays til u take it off I've tried them all this by far is number one
What happened??!
PLEASE BRING BACK THE OLD FORMULA THAT STAYS PUT! This version is drying and doesn't last as long. ALSO BRING BACK THE DARK GREEN!!! 😭😭
Great products line but can not sharpen it
I tried to sharpen it with cosmetic sharpener but it's not working. I bought essence Duo sharpener thought maybe works better no chance
Am I missing something?
I bought the gel eyeliner and I really like it. But! You get, like, a 1/4 of an inch! I feel like there's more in the pencil, and, if so, how do I get it out?? It doesn't twist and you can't sharpen, so what am I missing??
Bring back the Extreme Lasting Liner
What happened to the extreme lasting liner???? Bring back Black Midnight Sky
It's a plastic tip ?
Website says to sharpen it but it has a plastic tip and no way to push more out to be able to sharpen. I lol be the color and the feel of the product but what a waste.
WAAA WAAAA WAAAA:(
i purchased this as a new line to try. i love the rasin color as i have green/blue eyes and its a color that is a go to for me. the first time wearing it it was ok i use it on my upper waterline as well as lower.. it clumped in my lashes and bleed onto my skin. i was not outside nor sweaty. By the end of the day it had made its way to the corners of my eyes!!! i tried it out a few more times. did not go on and stay in place as i used it more. now its rounded and i used the sharpener and that made the tip fall off so i had to sharpen more. it fell off again as i was reapplying it. I'm not at all impressed with this product aside from the color.
Love this eyeliner BUT
Would really love it in the darker blue like deep sea baby.





