Most liked negative review

Not for straight stubborn lashes

I recently tried the Rimmel London Thrill Seeker Waterproof Mascara in the shade black, and as someone with straight, stubborn lashes, I always opt for waterproof formulas to ensure a lasting hold. However, my initial impressions left me a bit skeptical. Upon opening the mascara, I noticed that the... formula seemed wetter than typical waterproof mascaras. Waterproof variants usually have a drier consistency to enhance the longevity of the curl, but this one deviated from that norm. When applied, it performed adequately, though it didn't quite meet the standards of some other waterproof mascaras I've tried. One notable aspect is that it didn't hold up as well throughout the day as I had hoped. For those with naturally long lashes and double eyelids, this mascara might work better, providing the desired length and definition. However, for individuals like myself with monolids, the formula seemed to weigh down my lashes, making it challenging to maintain a lifted appearance. While the mascara did an acceptable job of adding volume and darkness to my lashes, the struggle with holding a curl was a notable drawback for me. It's possible that with certain eye shapes, this mascara could deliver more favorable results, but for those with monolids, the curl-holding aspect may not be as effective. In conclusion, the Rimmel London Thrill Seeker Waterproof Mascara may suit individuals with specific lash types and eye shapes. If you already have naturally curled lashes and double eyelids, you might find this mascara more accommodating. However, for those with straight lashes and monolids like myself, it might not be the ideal choice as it struggles to maintain a lasting curl throughout the day. In addition to my experience with the Rimmel London Thrill Seeker Waterproof Mascara, it's worth noting that the mascara wand bears a striking resemblance to the wand used in the popular "Better Than Sex" mascara. The similarity in design caught my attention, and I couldn't help but draw comparisons between the two. The mascara wand features a voluminous shape with densely packed bristles, intended to provide both length and volume to the lashes. While the design is reminiscent of the Better Than Sex mascara, the performance didn't quite match up, especially in terms of maintaining a curled lash look throughout the day. The resemblance to the Better Than Sex wand may attract those who appreciate the design of that particular mascara, but it's essential to manage expectations regarding the performance, as the results can vary. Despite the similarities in wand design, the Rimmel London Thrill Seeker Waterproof Mascara didn't quite deliver the same level of curl retention and longevity that I've experienced with other mascaras. Ultimately, if you're a fan of the Better Than Sex mascara wand and are curious to try a more budget-friendly option, the Rimmel London Thrill Seeker Waterproof Mascara might be worth considering. However, it's crucial to be aware that the performance might not be identical, particularly in terms of maintaining a curled lash appearance throughout the day.